
I don't say this often because it doesn't happen often, but Pesce is a good value for fantastic food. We left stuffed to the gills having spent under $35 a head. Granted, we didn't have any alcohol with this meal, but $35 in San Francisco usually means you're either merely un-hungry or have had mediocre food. Pesce was pronounced uniformly delicious, and better knowledge of the menu could have brought the price of dinner down even further. It's definitely worth recommending to people, as well as a return visit.
The smoked fish trio was a nice start, and the only cold dish we ordered. Two of us preferred the salmon, which was well marbled, thinkly sliced, and quite oily (in the good way). The other two liked the sturgeon, and even the two who liked salmon better agreed it was much more moist and flavorful than most smoked sturgeon. No one really cared for the trout, unfortunately. The horseradish cream had a nice texture, but could have used a spicier kick in order to stand up to the strong fish. Instead, it was almost like whipped cream. The capers, onions, and iceberg lettuce were very fresh, crisp, sweet, and simple.
The octopus salad with potatoes came highly recommened by Chowhound. I thought the flavors were nice, but that the octopus could have been more tender.
The swordfish rolls, for me, were the most boring dish of the evening. It was nice, but was a bit stingily portioned and not as delicious as everything else tonight. It was basically swordfish rolled around pine nuts and capers, with some oregano. I am just not a big fan of oregano in general.
Fortunately, the most disappointing dish of the evening was followed by my favorite dish of the evening: squid ink risotto. Wow. Perfectly cooked rice, tender with a slight bite, blackened by squid ink. The rice was buttery and creamy. The squid, however, really made the dish. They had an intense smokey flavor, were much more tender than the octopus had been, and had been stuffed with their own heads. So in one bite, you got the squid's body as well as its tentacles.
Drunken tuna cooked in red wine won the most unusual dish of the evening. We were aiming for a dinner made up entirely of seafood, but if I'd been blindfolded I would have declared this beef stew with a tomato wine sauce. It tasted like Chinese oxtail soup. Very good, and the grlled polenta was moist. I hate dry polenta.
Cioppino, the San Francisco treat. The soup was the best part of this version. It's obviously made with some great seafood stock, and very rich in flavor without being overpowered by tartness from tomatoes. There were clams, mussels, shrimp, fish, crab, and a piece of polenta at the bottom of the bowl, but the beautiful broth was the star.
By this time, I was so full I regretted having ordered our last dish, a whole snapper with a side of scalloped potatoes. But after the fish came, I was glad we did it. Not only was the fish beautifully baked with onions, tomatoes, capers, and kalamata olives, but it came with a dinner show! After bringing the fish to the table, our waitress split it open down the middle, picked out the tail and spine, expertly removed the side bones, took out the herbs that'd been stuffed inside, and put the fish together again! It's really hard to see the fish in this photo because of all the vegetables around it, but it really did look like a whole fish after she was done. She even left us the head, after first asking if that was our preference (of course it was!). It was a beautiful thing, and we oohed and aahed appreciatively. Her tip went up 5% just for that alone, even if she had already been charming and friendly all night long.
The fish comes with your choice of sides. The scalloped potatoes we got were intensely buttery and cheesy. They would have been great earlier in the meal, but it was really hard to finish it toward the end of the meal. Still, we tried. They were just that good. But next time, maybe some asparagus would be wiser.
We couldn't quit: we got a tiramisu to share. Look, they stencil fishies into it! The version of Pesce stands out for several reasons: the ladyfingers are soaked longer, the mascarpone is softer, the layer of cocoa powder is heavy, and the overall dessert is not cloyingly sweet or overpoweringly alcoholic. We liked it a lot.
Pesce has several menus: they hand you a cecchetti menu, which includes a few dozen choices of hot and cold small plates ($5-15). They have a raw bar menu with oysters and clams, which we skipped because we're going to Hog Island Oyster Company tomorrow. The entree menu has daily specials, which are $15-25. Finally, there's both a wine menu and a cocktail menu. Everything looked tempting, but we did exercise some degree of self control. Our two entrees tonight were the cioppino and snapper. As we were eating dessert, a plate of grilled prawns piled around a mountain of creamed fetta floated by to another table. Next time, next time! I also have to try their signature Venetian dessert drink, a mix of prosecco and lemon sorbet (I think).
Overall, the four of us agreed that the risotto and snapper were the best dishes of the night. They were also both a great value. Pesce's dishes all taste different from each other, but complement each other in a way that really makes a meal come together and has you looking forward to each dish. Aside from me feeling that things were a bit salty (but I always think that), it was perfect.
Pesce LLC
(415) 928-8025
2227 Polk Street (at Vallejo)
San Francisco, CA 94109
Citysearch link